Following the Ark of the Covenant: The Battle of Aphek and the Destruction of Shiloh

Share

Let’s go back in time 3,500, 4,000 years to get a sense of Shiloh and the surrounding settlements. The Middle Bronze Age, between 2000 BCE –1550 BCE, was characterized by the establishment of fortified cities, extensive commercial activity, advanced agriculture, and ties with Egypt, the ruling kingdom at that time. The first settlement at Shiloh was founded between 1550–1750 BCE, hundreds of years before the settlement of the Israelites. Towards the end of the period, the settlement was surrounded by significant fortifications, which are actually surprising in their size considering the relatively small area of ​​the site. The wall was based on large field stones. The thickness of the wall ranged from 3–5.5 meters and in certain sections it has been preserved to a height of 8 meters. The area inside the wall was excavated and many finds were discovered: dozens of jars, ritual vessels, Egyptian scarabs, bronze tools and weapons, rare silver jewellery, and many other finds. Shortly after the destruction of the site, in the 15 century BCE, activity at the site was resumed as a place of worship.

In the early 12th century BCE, when the place was abandoned, Israelite settlement began in Shiloh. Important remains from that period and the period of the judges were found. Impressive buildings discovered on the western slope of the hill were destroyed in a fierce fire. Black ash stains were found on the ground and piles of collapsed bricks and roof fragments were piled up. These are dramatic testimonies to the destruction of Shiloh by the Philistines in the mid-11th century BCE, as a result of Israel’s defeat at the Battle of Even HaEzer (also known as Eben-Ezer, or Aphek) which I will discuss in a moment. These buildings belong to the place where Elkanah brought his family once a year to sacrifice to God. It is here in Shiloh that the famous meeting between Hannah, Elkanah’s wife, and Eli the priest took place, and it is here that God revealed himself to Samuel when he was a boy whose purpose was to serve God. Shiloh, which was a pilgrimage center to which many offerings were brought, likely served much more than a place of worship, but rather an important economic center for the residents of the region.

The Battle of Even HaEzer described in the 1st book of Samuel:4 had a great influence on the Israelite history including the people’s demand for a king. The Philistines were stationed at Aphek near the springs of the Yarkon river, while the Israelite army was concentrated near Even HaEzer, which is identified with the settlement of ‘Izbet Zartah’ in the area of ​​Rosh HaAyin today. The book of Samuel does not specify what the Israelites and Philistines fought over, but if we look at the map of that period, it appears that Tel Aphek was an important point on the sea route connecting Egypt with northern Syria and Mesopotamia. Tel Aphek also resides on the water sources of the Yarkon river, which was once a wide and very important river. The Samaria Mountains are about 2km east of Aphek. In other words, a caravan traveling from Egypt to Syria, or to Assyria which was a regional power until after the destruction of the Kingdom of Israel, had to pass near Aphek in the passage between the springs of the Yarkon and the slopes of the Samaria Mountains. In that period, crossing the Yarkon river was a complex obstacle, so whoever controlled Tel Aphek effectively controlled a major crossing in Israel and also water sources, two good reasons to take control of the place. Archaeological excavations conducted at Tel Aphek indicate a large settlement spread over an area of ​​about 200 dunams that existed there from the third millennium BCE. A palace from the 14th century BCE was uncovered at the site, probably the home of an Egyptian governor. Researchers assume that in the 13th century BCE, the Egyptians built a control point on the international sea route.

The signs of destruction and burning, as well as arrowheads that were discovered, indicate that the structure was destroyed in battle, thus ending the Egyptian presence there. Who took control of the site? It is not surprising that the excavations found Philistine ceramics and the heads of ‘Ashdodah’ figurines, the likes of which were discovered for the first time in Philistine Ashdod. Meaning, the Philistines inherited the Egyptians’ site at Tel Aphek and thus expanded their area of ​​settlement northward to the banks of the Yarkon, and to the Aphek Pass, the important strategic crossing on the sea route (Via Maris). It seems that this was the drive for the war that broke out with the people of Israel, who lived between the slopes of the Samaria mountains and the southern coastal plain, where the Philistines lived.

As described in 1st book of Samuel:4, the Ark of the Covenant was taken from Shiloh to the battlefield, but Israel lost the battle and the Ark of the Covenant was taken captive. The Philistines took advantage of their victory, ascended from the coastal plain to the mountain, destroyed Shiloh and set it on fire. A man from the tribe of Benjamin ran from the scene of the war to Shiloh to deliver the bitter news to Eli the priest. The messenger told Eli that his two sons were killed in the battle, yet when Eli heard that the Ark of the Covenant was taken by the Philistines, he fell from his chair and died.

The result of the defeat to the Philistines was the immediate destruction of Shiloh. Most of the vessels remained in the buildings and were buried under the rubble, which is why an extremely rich assemblage of vessels was uncovered here. On the floor of one of the buildings, a pile of charred raisins was discovered in excellent condition, evidence of the last moments of Shiloh, whose inhabitants fled while the Philistines were knocking on its gates. Some of the walls and roof that collapsed covered large storage jars and pottery that were exposed, making it possible to date the destruction of Shiloh to the mid-11th century BCE. It is likely that due to its condition, the Ark of the Covenant was not returned to Shiloh even after the Philistines returned it, and it was placed in Kiryat Jearim.

After a period of abandonment, we receive signs of an active settlement in Shiloh during the monarchy period. From the book of Kings, we learn about the prophecy of Ahia from Shiloh, during the time of Jeroboam in the 10th century BCE, so people lived in Shiloh at the 10th century BCE. From the brief summary so far, two conclusions can be considered: First, there was continuity of worship in Shiloh from the mid-18th century BCE until the Israelite period, meaning that the Israelite tabernacle was built in a place where sacred traditions were already associated to it from earlier periods.

The fact that Shiloh was not an active site on the eve of the Israelite settlement, assisted with its selection and growth as a sacred Israeli center, since the first Israelites who came here found the place abandoned. The second conclusion: While the name Israel in reference to a group of people is already mentioned in an Egyptian victory monument of Pharaoh Merneptah, son of Ramesses II, at the end of the 13th century BCE, perhaps Shiloh as a ritual center and the settlements around it constituted the first settled territory of the people of Israel, and this was during the period of settlement. The centrality of Shiloh is striking when it becomes clear that in the immediate vicinity of Shiloh, the number of sites from that period is two to three times greater than in other areas of the Land of Ephraim. After the destruction of Shiloh, the Israeli center migrated south to the Mount Benjamin region and then to Jerusalem.

Let us focus for a moment on the importance of Shiloh, which was the sacred center for the Israelites during the period of the judges and the settlement, during the 12th century BCE to the mid-11th century BCE. Its importance is due to several reasons: (1) Shiloh was the place where the Tabernacle stood, and inside it stood the Ark of the Covenant, as it is written in the Book of Joshua, Chapter 18:1 (2) At Shiloh, as detailed in the Book of Joshua chapters 18-19, the division of the land was determined for the 7 remaining tribes: Benjamin, Simeon, Zebulun, Issachar, Asher, Naphtali, and Dan. (3) In Shiloh, the cities of the Levites were defined. Those were 48 cities designated for the Levite tribe who received no land inheritance. They included six cities of refuge as listed in the book of Joshua chapter 21:1-2. (4) During the period of settlement, Shiloh was the religious and political center of the tribes of Ephraim and Benjamin. According to the 1st book of Samuel chapter 1, the religious center in Shiloh was called “the house of God”. In the days of Eli the priest and his sons, it was customary to come to the place “to sacrifice to the Lord,” as described in the case of Elkanah, the father of Samuel (1 Samuel chapter 1:21). (5) In Shiloh, as described in the book of Judges chapter 21:19-21, a “Feast of the Lord in Shiloh” was held annually, an ancient festival, perhaps the harvest festival. The festival included dancing in the vineyards and is famous in connection with the “concubine on the hill” episode, in which the sons of Benjamin kidnapped the daughters of Shiloh, and I will not elaborate further on that.

The Hebrew Bible does not directly describe the end of Shiloh, but we learn about it from several sources. Psalms chapter 78:60 mentions the abandonment of Sheila. Jeremiah in his book chapter 26, refers to the destruction of the Temple as it was in Shiloh. In general, Shiloh appears many times throughout the Hebrew Bible, which positions the place as an important site whose memory is deeply embedded throughout the biblical period and even beyond.

According to some scholars, we are facing here (on the northern slopes of Shiloh) the Location of the Tabernacle in Shiloh. It is possible that it was here within the boundary created by the two rock walls on the north and south. The dimensions of the surface are 50 cubits wide, corresponding to the dimensions of the Tabernacle courtyard detailed in the book of Exodus chapter 27:9-13. There are many studies regarding its possible location, including a proposal to identify it at the peak of the mound or in the southern part, but I will not elaborate further on this issue.

Tel Shiloh is located in the center of the Land of Ephraim. The mound, which covers an area of ​​about 30 dunams, is surrounded by slopes from the east, north, and west. Access to it is only convenient from the south, and this was probably the entrance to the site in ancient times. On the top of the mound and on its southern slope are the remains of sites from later periods.

During the Byzantine period, churches were built on the site that have been dated by excavators to the 6th century. This basilica, is 18×15 meters. The structure includes a central hall and two side aisles. On the western side of the basilica is an entrance hall with a mosaic floor decorated with geometric patterns.

Here, a prayer site from the Mamluk period was built on the foundation of two churches that were destroyed during the Arab conquest, when some of the items were repurposed. Among other things, a fragment of an altar of horns was found in the wall of the church. The mosaic from the Byzantine period is impressive and contains an inscription of a prayer for the peace of the residents of Shiloh. The Arabs call the Shiloh Valley by two additional names: Sahl al-Eid (Valley of the Feast) and Sahl al-Banat (Valley of the Girls), perhaps related to the “concubine on the hill” episode, in which the sons of Benjamin kidnapped the daughters of Shiloh.

Shiloh Spring, less than a kilometre away, preserved its name as Ein Saylon by the locals throughout history. The spring served as a stable source of water for Shiloh throughout its periods.

The identification of Shiloh’s location is certain, based on the description in the Book of Judges chapter 21. Another source is Eusebius, bishop of the church from Caesarea in the fourth century, who stated that Shiloh is located 12 miles or 18 km away from Nablus. Biblical names are preserved throughout the generations in Arab names, and thus the name Shiloh is preserved in the name of this spring, Ein Saylon, and the locals call the archaeological mound “Horvat Saylon,” and of course the fact that the archaeological finds at the site correspond to the history of Shiloh – all of these lead to a certain identification of its location. And finally, as usual I have a question for you. Who was the last judge before the monarchy period? The answer will appear at the end of the video.

How to get there?

Ancient Shiloh is a well-organized site. Opening hours are listed on its website: https://a-shiloh.co.il.

Waypoint: 32.054343897489694, 35.28998383450046

Information Sources

  1. Qadmoniot: Journal for the Antiquities of Eretz-Israel and Bible Lands, Issue 65, "The Excavations at Shiloh (1981–1983)," by Israel Finkelstein, Shlomo Bonimovitz, and Zvi Lederman, Publisher: Israel Exploration Society
  2. Book: Digging Up the Bible: On the Bible and Archaeology; Author: Yitzhak Meitlis, Publisher: Rubin Mass
  3. Book: Derech Eretz: Stone, Pottery, and Man; Editor: Irit Zaharoni; Publisher: Ministry of Defense
  4. Book: Biblical Encyclopedia; Editor: Benjamin Mazar; Publisher: Bialik Institute
  5. Book: The New Israel Guide: Vol. 7: Samaria and the Jordan Valley; Editors: Menachem Marcus and Sefi Ben-Yosef; Publishers: Keter Books and the Ministry of Defense

Mention in the Bible

  1. Exodus chapter 27 verses 9–13
  2. Joshua chapter 18 verses 1–4
  3. Joshua chapter 21 verses 1–2
  4. Judges chapter 21 verses 19–21
  5. 1 Samuel chapter 1 verses 9, 21, 24
  6. 1 Samuel chapter 4
  7. Jeremiah chapter 26 verse 6
  8. Psalms chapter 78 verse 60

Related Sites